Nutrisystem Promo Code for Existing Customers? Use “Costco” Hack

If you are on Nutrisystem or thinking of joining, you’ve probably noticed that all of their promo codes are for your first order only. So, is there a way for existing customers to get a discount on your second order, or towards a la carte food?

The good news is that we’ve found a hack that works for existing customers towards their second and subsequent orders, but you have to be a Costco member.

The Secret is buying Nutrisystem Gift Cards at at up to a 40% discount!

Are you a member of Costco? Perhaps you have a family member or close friend who has a Costco membership? If so, you are eligible to buy discounted Nutrisystem gift cards in-store or at

costco nutrisystem discount

These $100 gift cards cost only $59-79 each, and can be used towards your first order, or a la carte food thereafter. Here’s how:

First Order

If you are joining Nutrisystem, (does it work?) there are promo codes available to save big at signup.

However, you can also buy multiple discount $100 gift cards to use towards your first order to save even more. So, if your first order is $350, you can buy up to 4 discounted Costco gift cards to use towards the total.

Just enter the code at checkout just like a promo code where it says, “enter gift card.” It’s a great way to save big when you join!

But, you may notice that you can’t enter a promo code for your second order. Here’s a hack to get a discount as an existing customer:

Second Order:

So, you’ve already completed the first part of Nutrisystem (FreshStart®) and are ready for more?

While there are no promo codes out there for existing Nutrisystem customers, you can use the balance of a gift card just like a promo code at checkout.

Example: If your first order total is $350 and you use 4 x $100 gift cards, you are left with a balance of $50.

The good news is that you can use that balance towards your second order! Just be sure to save the gift card with a remaining balance, as you will have to enter the code again towards your second order, including a la carte Nutrisystem food anytime.

A la Carte Food

buy nutrisystem food a la carte

Want to keep using these discounted Nutrisystem gift cards towards every order? Here’s where it’s a bit tricky, because when you signup for Nutrisystem, they put you on auto-payment. If you cancel before your second month, you’ll owe a $125 cancellation fee.

So, what can do you save money and beat the system?

Once again it comes back to the discount Nutrisystem gift cards. Here’s what you can do:

After your first two orders, you can log into your account and choose to delay your shipments.

Instead of receiving your third (or later) shipment, you can order food a la carte through your account at, using the discount Costco Nutrisystem gift cards.

*Related: South Beach Diet Costco Gift Cards: 25-40% Discount!

Existing Customers Can Still Save!

So, while by definition this isn’t a promo code for your second order, it’s a hack to get Nutrisystem food through your account at up to a 40% discount!

From this point on you can resume your auto-delivery shipments at any time, or continue ordering Nutrisystem food a la carte at a big discount; it’s up to you!

If you aren’t loving Nutrisystem, you can even quit after the second month without fear of a cancellation fee.

To get the most out of this hack, watch the price of Nutrisystem gift cards at Costco. While the regular price for these $100 cards is $79, you can find them on sale for as cheap as $59 each. That’s like finding a promo code for a 40% discount for existing customers!

Are you a Costco member? If so, check out today’s price on Nutrisystem gift cards here.

Other Promo Codes & Coupons?

If you aren’t a Nutrisystem member yet, we have exclusive coupons to get you the best price when you join. We recommend skipping the tempting 50 percent off sale, and going with the “

Not sold on Nutrisystem? We also have exclusive coupons for Weight Watchers (WW) and up to $100 off the cost of joining the South Beach Diet.

(Oh, and during tax season we can save you up to $25 on TurboTax with this coupon!)

Need inspiration? We just put together a list of our favorite weight loss quotes here.

Regardless of how you choose to strive towards your health and weight loss goals, good luck!

Sharing is caring!

Related Posts